Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 04/29/2017

John Sherman, MD

88.2% Patient Satisfaction based on 39 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for John Sherman, MD . You can also see locations, or contact John Sherman right here at RealPatientRatings®.

Based on 39 ratings
5 stars (27)
4 stars (5)
3 stars (4)
2 stars (2)
1 star (1)
Doctor's bedside manner
Medical support team
Admin staff
Care & concern
Educated me
Wait time
Value for the price
Likelihood to recommend
Facility & amenities


About, locations & contact info

About John Sherman:

John. E. Sherman, MD is a plastic surgeon in practice in New York City for over 30 years. He is one of the few senior surgeons who has a well-respected cosmetic and aesthetic practice, and also teaches trauma and reconstruction. The cosmetic procedures are performed in his fully accredited operating facility, or at one of New York’s finest Hospitals.


Board Certification

American Board of Plastic Surgery

Contact This Provider

1016 5th Avenue New York, NY 10028

Sort options
Search filters
Service type
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
John Sherman, MD Reviews (21)

Face Lift

Great from start to finish


I was satisfied knowing that Dr. Sherman will review my case (face) in January , 2019


The price I paid the service which was told to me will be provided There is a big disparity The surgeon does not listen to the patient’sconcern

Face Lift

Dr Sherman is remarkable in making you looked refreshed and natural. I trust him not to have a plastic surgery look yet achieve the results I wanted They take care of you 100% from beginning to end. Dr Sherman is involved and personally calls prior to surgery regarding any last minute concerns and then is checking in thru out recovery in next 24 hours following


Dr Sherman and staff very professional It hasn’t changed my everyday life but made me more confident about my appearance

Breast Lift

Dr. Sherman and his staff are exceptionally experienced, well-organized and most importantly caring. I am completely satisfied and would recommend Dr. Sherman to all!


Doctor listened to what I wanted and did exactly what I wanted. I broke my noise in high school and it was crooked and hurt to wear glasses. I now wear glasses all the time and wanted the glasses to be comfortable.Problem solved, looks great and I can breath better.

Breast Lift

My outcome was better than I expected and I am super happy and feel great. I didn't expect to NOT have any complaints, but I don't have a single one!


Great doctor, easy to talk to, good outcome/results.


Dr Sherman and his team made me feel very comfortable throughout the whole procedure and were very professional. More confidence and better feel about my overall appearance

Breast Implant Revision

I have already written why I was dissatisfied in an earlier question.

Breast Augmentation

Everyone made me feel comfortable, which was important pre surgery. The facility was clean and beautiful. I felt well cared for and listened to. My recovery was very easy. And I love my result. The people working on me all made me feel very safe and comfortable

Face Lift

Outstanding physician! Professional and caring staff that go above and beyond to ensure the patient's comfort and satisfaction. Dr. Sherman is honest and committed to his patients. Extremely satisfied with my care and results. I have have nothing bit praise for this practice.

Eyelid Surgery

Very attentive doctor, board certified, excellent facility. Satisfied with my appearance so far

Face Lift

Consistently professional and caring office led by a Dr with great expertise. A patient for more than 30 yrs and very satisfied. The feeling of confidence from speaking with Dr Sherman that we were on the same page regarding the surgery and outcome.

Neck Lift

Dr and support staff excellent very knowledgable and caring...important for a first timer like myself.End results very natural. I look and feel younger.


The staff was great and extremely friendly, but that doesn't make up for the fact that I had multiple surgeries with this doctor and the results have always been subpar. And I'm not one of those people who expects perfection, but we removed cartilage from my ear to go to my nose (which months later still feels weird and hurt WAY more than my nose did) and the left side of my nose is collapsed and scarred! It also somehow looks more crooked than the last surgery, but maybe that's because of the dent. I regret not going to a younger doctor.

Breast Augmentation

Whole process was seamless and Dr. Sherman made the entire nerve racking process very easy going. I was at ease the entire time. He knew exactly what size would be appropriate for my shape without me being able to articulate fully. So happy with the results. I was walking around literally after the second day with minimal pain. Surprisingly no changes to my everyday life.

Face Lift

This is the second time I visited Dr. Sherman. I was totally satisfied the first time when he operated on my eyes and chin. I returned 10 years later for further assistance. I was very impressed first time around so it was an easy decision to return to him. I felt confident in him and his staff to help if any problem arose. None did

Breast Reduction

Extremely professional services .Dr. Sherman is an artist and I am completely satisfied with my results.