Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 11/30/2011

Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD

97.2% Patient Satisfaction based on 161 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD . You can also see locations, or contact Tracy M. Pfeifer right here at RealPatientRatings®.

Based on 161 ratings
5 stars (139)
4 stars (22)
3 stars (0)
2 stars (0)
1 star (0)
Doctor's bedside manner
Medical support team
Admin staff
Care & concern
Educated me
Wait time
Value for the price
Likelihood to recommend
Facility & amenities


About, locations & contact info

About Tracy M. Pfeifer:

Dr. Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD, MS is a plastic surgeon specializing in all of the most rewarding and beneficial procedures in cosmetic surgery, including breast augmentation, body contouring, facial plastic surgery, and skin rejuvenation procedures. Dr. Pfeifer offers a special emphasis on surgery of the breast, with extensive training and experience that has distinguished her within the field.

As one of New York's elite few female plastic surgeons, Dr. Pfeifer is well attuned to the aesthetic concerns of her patients. Her specialized training in plastic surgery of the breast further distinguishes her within the field. 

Dr. Pfeifer's philosophy is a commitment to excellence and providing each patient with a warm and personalized focus on their needs. Through patient education, we help patients make informed choices that are in their best interest. The ultimate goal is a satisfied patient with an excellent aesthetic result.

Board Certification

American Board of Plastic Surgery
American Board of Surgery

Contact This Provider

1175 Park Ave New York, NY 10128

25 Montauk Highway Quogue, NY 11959

Sort options
Search filters
Service type
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD Reviews (110)

Breast Augmentation

I was never pressured to go bigger. My dance career and small frame were considered in helping me choose size and shape. I'm truly happy with my results. They look natural and proportionate which is exactly what I wanted. My own personal confidence is probably the best part of my results. I love the way they look and as a professional performer confidence is extremely important.

Breast Reduction

Pre surgery was fantastic. Not only did they help me with insurance, they gave me all the information on how to prepare. Post surgery was no different. Dr. Pfeifer directly called me the day after my surger to check on me. The nurses and consultants called and texted me around the clock multiple times a day. I have seen Dr. Pfeifer every week post surgery for post-op check ups. We finally scheduled them every two weeks but I still feel like I can call her with anything. Day or night. I could not have asked for a better experience. I'm still healing but the biggest change has been the positive outlook I now have towards myself and my body. I knew this surgery wasn't going solve all of my problems but its given me the confidence I've been missing. The more I heal the better I become and the more confidence I have in myself. I am so excited to finally start working out again. Pushing my limits and giving myself the strength I've been longing more, mentally, physically and emotionally!

Breast Augmentation

Dr Pfeifer is the best of the best. As a physician myself we understand patient physician competency and relationships. Even in the midst of difficult circumstances, Dr Pfeifer has the ability to navigate, direct and employ her knowlegde. It’s a rare trait and should not be understated.

Breast Augmentation

I could not have asked for a better experience with Dr. Pfiefer and her team. I always felt comfortable and informed with everything going on. I felt taken care of and was never left unsure. I appreciate everything she and her team have done to make my experience a fabulous one. I am so happy with my results I feel way more confident than I ever have

Juvéderm® XC

Satisfied and happy with the results

Lip Enhancement

Great staff

Breast Lift

Before my tummy tuck I would literally need to lift the skin and actually put deodorant or power the area. There wasn't a day that went by where I couldn't wear spanx to keep the extra skin in place with my clothing. Since my tummy tuck I can just put on any pair of jeans and go! No tucked in tanks! It is honestly like a new found freedom. I have had 2 surgical procedures performed by Dr. Pfieffer and see her several times a year for Botox/ Dysport injections. I could not be more satisfied by every aspect of her and her staff. I recommend her to anyone I know who's pondering having any sort of treatment. Dr. Pfieffer and her staff are amazing and caring women.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

The smile it put on my face. Friendliness and expert professional services

BOTOX® Cosmetic

I've been getting botox with Dr. Pfeifer for years and love how it smoothes out my forehead lines. Dr. Pfeifer is the best, as is her patient coordinator, Maureen.

Breast Augmentation

The doctor listened to my expectations and the results were exactly what I had hoped for. It was clear the doctor was extremely experienced at these throes of surgeries.

Breast Lift

The staff can make or break a practice no matter how great the surgeon is. I cannot get over the way I was spoken to and treated by one staff member in particular. As previously mentioned I felt that this staff member treated me with no respect whatsoever and because the surgery was over and the fees paid, I was no longer important enough to be treated as a patient.

BOTOX® Cosmetic


Breast Augmentation

The best thing about the procedure was the way that Dr. Pheifer plans and executes surgery so that recovery is as bearable as possible. . Dr. Pheifer and her team are true experts. At every stage of the experience I felt listened to, cared for and cared about. Further, Dr. Pheifer is an artist and her worknis truly beautiful. 5 months after surgery and sometimes I even forget I’ve had a procedure done. Everything is so natural.

Breast Reduction

I fell like myself again, and am no longer burdened by heavy breasts. This is my second procedure with this surgeon. She is not only a skilled artist, she is kind, patient, and takes time to clearly explain things. Her follow-up is amazing, and her office staff top-notch as well. I have recommended her to others and will continue to do so.


Office staff is extremely personable and helpful. Dr. Pfeiffer is an expert in her field. She is very skilled and cares about her patients. Results are always natural.

Breast Implant Revision

Excellent doctor and staff Highly satisfied with results

Breast Reduction

Dr. Pfeifer and her staff are absolutely amazing! My breast reduction changed my life! The results are incredible as Dr. Pfeifer is very meticulous! I had a very positive experience for such my major surgery and couldn’t have asked for a better staff to perform it! The recovery was easier than I thought and Dr. Pfeifer and staff were available at any point during my recovery. There were no issues at all. I no longer have back/ shoulder pains and no shoulder dents from my bra straps. I highly recommend Dr. Pfeifer if you are getting a breast reduction.


I trust Tracy so much. Tracy is a perfectionist

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Dr Pfeifer is the most wonderful human being, most skilled doctor, and a true artist.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Always pleasurable, afterward I feel refreshed!