Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 12/03/2019

Caitlin McCarthy, MD

97% Patient Satisfaction based on 325 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for Caitlin McCarthy, MD . You can also learn more, see locations, or contact Caitlin McCarthy right here at RealPatientRatings®.

4.85
Based on 325 ratings
5 stars (283)
87.1%
4 stars (35)
10.8%
3 stars (6)
1.8%
2 stars (1)
0.3%
1 star (0)
0.0%
About, locations & contact info

About Caitlin McCarthy:

Special Interests

  • Normal and high risk pregnancies
  • Preconception counseling
  • Minimally invasive surgery
  • Adolescent gynecology
  • Contraceptive care and counseling

Background

Dr. McCarthy was born and raised on the west side of Cincinnati. She and her husband have a baby boy and they are enjoying family life and all that Cincinnati has to offer. In her free time, she enjoys dance and theater, trying new restaurants and watching football in the fall.

Education and Certification

  • Undergraduate degree: Xavier University, 2007
  • Medical degree: University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 2011
  • Residency in Obstetrics and Gynecology: Medical College of Wisconsin, 2015
  • Board certified, American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology
Sort options
Search filters
Service type
Reviewer
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
Caitlin McCarthy, MD Reviews (99)

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Dr. McCarthy is very welcoming and easy to talk to. She passes no judgment and is very informative.

Annual Well Woman Exam

I was worried whether to go for an appointment with COVID. I appreciate how you wait by the door before going inside for an appointment. When you exit you go through a different door. I did not have to wait long in the waiting room. Dr. McCarthy was excellent in taking time with me and asking me if I have any questions or concerns. This was my first visit with her.

Annual Well Woman Exam

This was my first visit with Dr. McCarthy and she was very friendly and I felt comfortable with her.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Dr. McCarthy was extremely attentive and helpful with every question I had.

New Patient Visit

[Highly satisfied] Because of their good hospitality.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Everything was great. Especially Dr. McCarthy. Love her!!!

New Patient Visit

Dr. McCarthy went above and beyond for me. She is kind, and extremely understanding and helpful. She is my first OBGYN and made me feel comfortable the entire time!

New Patient Visit

Dr. McCarthy really listened to what I had to say and answered all of my questions. She was proactive in her approach and helped ease my mind about different issues that might be going on.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Staff was very friendly and there was no wait time

Annual Well Woman Exam

Very professional, made me feel comfortable.

New Patient Visit

I had to bring my young daughter and Dr. McCarthy was so kind and understanding and thorough with her (and me).

New Patient Visit

Dr. McCarthy had an excellent bedside manner and made me feel like I was a priority. I didn't feel rushed and she answered all my questions putting my mind at ease.

Ultrasound

I liked the doctor. She was friendly and patient.

IUD Insertion / Removal

Doctor McCarthy is amazing and made me feel extremely comfortable the whole time.

Obstetrical Ultrasound

[Highly satisfied with] Attention of staff, bedside manner.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Quick easy but thorough.

Obstetrical Ultrasound

Dr. McCarthy is fantastic!

Gynecological Problem Visit

Very easy to talk with Dr. McCarthy.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

The team at Mercy West is highly efficient and polite. Dr. McCarthy is always a pleasure to work with and always answers any of my questions knowledgeably.

Gynecological Problem Visit

She is so wonderful and professional.