Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 12/03/2019

Caitlin McCarthy, MD

96.6% Patient Satisfaction based on 155 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for Caitlin McCarthy, MD . You can also learn more, see locations, or contact Caitlin McCarthy right here at RealPatientRatings®.

4.83
Based on 155 ratings
5 stars (133)
85.8%
4 stars (17)
11.0%
3 stars (5)
3.2%
2 stars (0)
0.0%
1 star (0)
0.0%
About, locations & contact info

About Caitlin McCarthy:

Special Interests

  • Normal and high risk pregnancies
  • Preconception counseling
  • Minimally invasive surgery
  • Adolescent gynecology
  • Contraceptive care and counseling

Background

Dr. McCarthy was born and raised on the west side of Cincinnati. She and her husband have a baby boy and they are enjoying family life and all that Cincinnati has to offer. In her free time, she enjoys dance and theater, trying new restaurants and watching football in the fall.

Education and Certification

  • Undergraduate degree: Xavier University, 2007
  • Medical degree: University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 2011
  • Residency in Obstetrics and Gynecology: Medical College of Wisconsin, 2015
  • Board certified, American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology
Sort options
Search filters
Service type
Reviewer
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
Caitlin McCarthy, MD Reviews (44)

Ultrasound

Was talked threw the whole thing was shown concern of my well being and reassured of my well being.

Gynecological Problem Visit

Dr. McCarthy is a wonderful doctor. She is very knowledgeable and understanding of her patient's needs.

IUD Insertion / Removal

Doctor and nurse were both professional and nice, insertion went well.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Was highly satisfied because staff was very nice to me, doctor was friendly.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Very professional.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Dr. McCarthy took her time with me. She sat down and had a conversation with me and discussed my concerns about nausea/vomiting and migraines. She even prescribed some relief which I had not previously received.

Gynecological Problem Visit

We discussed a treatment for a problem I was experiencing, so I left with an action plan.

Annual Well Woman Exam

All ran very smoothly even with COVID restrictions. Everyone I encountered was polite and helpful. My first visit since Dr. Wiwi retired and I was very happy with Dr. McCarthy. She was thorough and answered all my questions.

Gynecological Problem Visit

Everyone was very kind and helped me to feel welcome and comfortable.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Front desk is always amazing. I was also late and forgot my insurance card and no one made a fuss, I was still in and out in a timely manner!

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Kind staff, short wait, good social distancing and cleanliness.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Although I was HIGHLY satisfied with the care I received- from the front desk, ultrasound technique, medical assistant, and doctor, I just wish spouses were allowed to join for the ultrasounds. I completely understand the precautions being taken due to COVID. However, it would be so much better if we were allowed to bring 1 visitor with us to the ultrasound. This is my first baby, and it's just hard that I had to go to my anatomy scan alone and that my husband could not be there to see. I feel like precautions, such as having my husband wait outside until I am called back, having him wear a mask, and having his temperature checked would have been following the same precautions I had to take.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Dr. McCarthy has always made the appointment as comfortable as she can. She has great energy that can instantly calm a person if they're nervous. She answered all my questions and made sure I was satisfied with her answers before moving onto another subject. It took me years searching for a gyno that I was comfortable with and I'm glad I can finally say she is perfect for me.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Great staff, clean and welcoming office, no lines, no waiting time.

Gynecological Problem Visit

health precautions in place, nurses and other staff very courteous and timely with appointment

New Patient Visit

Office is nice & clean. Receptionist did a great job observing all safety measures for COVID-19. Dr. McCarthy was VERY nice. She really listened to all concerns and asked clarifying questions. Provided several options for my issues and discussed each of them with me thoroughly.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Doctor McCarthy is always kind and knowledgeable. I appreciate her honest opinion as well as her quick and discreet exams

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

The MA asked if I had any questions for Dr McCarthy. She communicated those questions to Dr. McCarthy and she addressed them during my appointment. She is so friendly and really listens, I feel heard.

Annual Well Woman Exam

I love Dr McCarthy- my second time seeing her and my first time seeing her for my "yearly." I would love to keep seeing her. She is so sweet and kind and really makes me feel as ease.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Dr. McCarthy always explains things In a very sincere way. I always look forward to my visits with her.