Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 12/03/2019

Caitlin McCarthy, MD

96.6% Patient Satisfaction based on 242 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for Caitlin McCarthy, MD . You can also learn more, see locations, or contact Caitlin McCarthy right here at RealPatientRatings®.

4.83
Based on 242 ratings
5 stars (208)
86.0%
4 stars (27)
11.2%
3 stars (6)
2.5%
2 stars (1)
0.4%
1 star (0)
0.0%
About, locations & contact info

About Caitlin McCarthy:

Special Interests

  • Normal and high risk pregnancies
  • Preconception counseling
  • Minimally invasive surgery
  • Adolescent gynecology
  • Contraceptive care and counseling

Background

Dr. McCarthy was born and raised on the west side of Cincinnati. She and her husband have a baby boy and they are enjoying family life and all that Cincinnati has to offer. In her free time, she enjoys dance and theater, trying new restaurants and watching football in the fall.

Education and Certification

  • Undergraduate degree: Xavier University, 2007
  • Medical degree: University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 2011
  • Residency in Obstetrics and Gynecology: Medical College of Wisconsin, 2015
  • Board certified, American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology
Sort options
Search filters
Service type
Reviewer
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
Caitlin McCarthy, MD Reviews (73)

Annual Well Woman Exam

My doctor always go above and beyond.

New Patient Visit

Caring.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Doctor McCarthy was very friendly and made me feel comfortable in a situation that I think is uncomfortable. The staff is always kind and on time.

Annual Well Woman Exam

The staff was nice. My wait time was not long. All of my questions answered.

Gynecological Problem Visit

McCarthy is always very nice, patient and listens to what's going on. Not sure if it's just because the office is smaller but the Harrison location staff has always been very friendly and attentive.

Annual Well Woman Exam

The office was clean & meeting all the COVID protocols. I didn't have to wait & limited number of people in the waiting room. I love my doctor. She is very passionate & concerned for my well being.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Was seen quickly. Dr. McCarthy was friendly and asked a lot of questions.

Annual Well Woman Exam

The doctor and staff were polite, knowledgeable and professional.

New Patient Visit

The MA and Dr. McCarthy are very personable and don't talk to you like you're an idiot. They both genuinely care about their patients and the reputation of the agency. Answered questions and explained everything that was to be expected during the visit.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Everything was quick.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Safe environment with a friendly and efficient staff. Dr. McCarthy performed the most comfortable pap I have ever experienced. I first came to Dr. McCarthy two years ago after being unhappy with my previous doctor. I was experiencing irregular menstrual cycles for almost 3 years until Dr. McCarthy helped me find alternative birth control methods. I've been regular ever since.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Doctor spent adequate time with me answering my questions. Didn't feel rushed.

IUD Insertion / Removal

Great explanations and questions answered honestly. The staff took my well being into account in every step of both procedures.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Everyone was professional, polite and efficient!

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

I came into my appointment emotionally unstable and crying due to a family issue. I was unable to compose myself and found some comfort in the support and gentle sympathy provided to me by the nurses and Doctor McCarthy. Doctor McCarthy is a very friendly, knowledgeable woman and she makes me feel very safe. I'd be quite happy if she were my attending doctor when I go into labor.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Dr. McCarthy is my favorite doctor at Mercy West!

New Patient Visit

Clean, seamless check in process. Didn't wait long to be seen.

New Patient Visit

I was extremely impressed and happy with the office and doctor. Everyone was friendly. Dr. McCarthy was very informative and caring. She never rushed and gave me enough time to ask questions.

Annual Well Woman Exam

It was the first time I saw Dr. McCarthy, having been a patient of Dr. Wiwi until his retirement. I found her to be very nice and appreciated that she knew my history. I look forward to continuing under her care.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Felt welcomed by the receptionist the medical assistant and the doctor. And I wasn't there long at all.