Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 12/03/2019

Caitlin McCarthy, MD

97% Patient Satisfaction based on 355 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for Caitlin McCarthy, MD . You can also learn more, see locations, or contact Caitlin McCarthy right here at RealPatientRatings®.

4.85
Based on 355 ratings
5 stars (310)
87.3%
4 stars (38)
10.7%
3 stars (6)
1.7%
2 stars (1)
0.3%
1 star (0)
0.0%
About, locations & contact info

About Caitlin McCarthy:

Special Interests

  • Normal and high risk pregnancies
  • Preconception counseling
  • Minimally invasive surgery
  • Adolescent gynecology
  • Contraceptive care and counseling

Background

Dr. McCarthy was born and raised on the west side of Cincinnati. She and her husband have a baby boy and they are enjoying family life and all that Cincinnati has to offer. In her free time, she enjoys dance and theater, trying new restaurants and watching football in the fall.

Education and Certification

  • Undergraduate degree: Xavier University, 2007
  • Medical degree: University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 2011
  • Residency in Obstetrics and Gynecology: Medical College of Wisconsin, 2015
  • Board certified, American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology
Sort options
Search filters
Service type
Reviewer
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
Caitlin McCarthy, MD Reviews (109)

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Nice and fast service and so kind to all.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Dr. McCarthy is a very good doctor.

Annual Well Woman Exam

It was very smooth experience.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Dr. Dennis Wiwi was my doctor for over 30 years. When he retired he suggested that I allow Dr. Caitlin McCarthy to become my doctor. She was extremely friendly, asked me questions about my health and about myself and was a good listener and made me feel very comfortable. I was glad she was recommended to me and look forward to having her be my gynecologist from here on out.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Everything was so safe and professional. I did not have to wait long at all, things moved along on time. Dr. McCarthy is great. She's knowledgeable and really listens to what you're saying. She explains what's going on in terms you can understand.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Dr. McCarthy and all of the staff are always such a joy to see! Always so friendly, easy to converse with, incredibly competent and smooth-running, professional. I've always felt so comfortable and safe, and I appreciate that so much.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

I'm highly satisfied because all of the doctors I have met are super nice and caring, I haven't met Dr. Gibler but I do on March 9th, I haven't decided who I want to deliver my son yet but I will soon!

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

This was my first visit with Dr. McCarthy, and my first visit with this group of doctors since I just switched. I was very pleased with my visit. I felt like Dr. McCarthy took the time to make sure all of my questions were answered and I really felt listened to. I was also very happy to hear that my blood work came back and I passed my glucose test. But the nurse informed me that my iron was low, so Dr. McCarthy was putting me on an iron supplement. I don't recall a full blood panel being done with my first two pregnancies, so the fact that beyond my glucose levels was checked, was very nice!

New Patient Visit

It was my first time going to see an OBGYN and I was really nervous. The staff and Doctor McCarthy made me feel very comfortable, relaxed, and quick! I really appreciated that. Also, everyone was very kind and made the process run smoothly. With COVID, I felt safe in the environment.

Gynecological Problem Visit

I was in and out of the office in a short time without feeling rushed. Dr McCarthy was kind and attentive. She knew what my issue was right away and was very reassuring. I'm glad she was in when I needed it.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Dr. McCarthy is very welcoming and easy to talk to. She passes no judgment and is very informative.

Annual Well Woman Exam

I was worried whether to go for an appointment with COVID. I appreciate how you wait by the door before going inside for an appointment. When you exit you go through a different door. I did not have to wait long in the waiting room. Dr. McCarthy was excellent in taking time with me and asking me if I have any questions or concerns. This was my first visit with her.

Annual Well Woman Exam

This was my first visit with Dr. McCarthy and she was very friendly and I felt comfortable with her.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Dr. McCarthy was extremely attentive and helpful with every question I had.

New Patient Visit

[Highly satisfied] Because of their good hospitality.

Obstetrical Appointment (routine)

Everything was great. Especially Dr. McCarthy. Love her!!!

New Patient Visit

Dr. McCarthy went above and beyond for me. She is kind, and extremely understanding and helpful. She is my first OBGYN and made me feel comfortable the entire time!

New Patient Visit

Dr. McCarthy really listened to what I had to say and answered all of my questions. She was proactive in her approach and helped ease my mind about different issues that might be going on.

Annual Well Woman Exam

Staff was very friendly and there was no wait time

Annual Well Woman Exam

Very professional, made me feel comfortable.