Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 11/30/2011

Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD

97.4% Patient Satisfaction based on 277 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD . You can also see locations, or contact Tracy M. Pfeifer right here at RealPatientRatings®.

Based on 277 ratings
5 stars (247)
4 stars (26)
3 stars (2)
2 stars (2)
1 star (0)
Doctor's bedside manner
Medical support team
Admin staff
Care & concern
Educated me
Wait time
Value for the price
Likelihood to recommend
Facility & amenities


About, locations & contact info

About Tracy M. Pfeifer:

Dr. Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD, MS is a plastic surgeon specializing in all of the most rewarding and beneficial procedures in cosmetic surgery, including breast augmentation, body contouring, facial plastic surgery, and skin rejuvenation procedures. Dr. Pfeifer offers a special emphasis on surgery of the breast, with extensive training and experience that has distinguished her within the field.

As one of New York's elite few female plastic surgeons, Dr. Pfeifer is well attuned to the aesthetic concerns of her patients. Her specialized training in plastic surgery of the breast further distinguishes her within the field. 

Dr. Pfeifer's philosophy is a commitment to excellence and providing each patient with a warm and personalized focus on their needs. Through patient education, we help patients make informed choices that are in their best interest. The ultimate goal is a satisfied patient with an excellent aesthetic result.

Board Certification

American Board of Plastic Surgery
American Board of Surgery

Contact This Provider

1125 5th Avenue New York, NY 10128

25 Montauk Highway Quogue, NY 11959

Sort options
Search filters
Service type
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD Reviews (195)

Breast Augmentation

Everyone was extremely professional and very genuine. I could tell from the first consultation that they genuinely wanted the best for me. From the beginning, they made me feel very comfortable. Throughout my journey, they felt like family to me. Any questions or concerned that I had, they would always reassure me and make sure to answer every question I had to make sure I felt comfortable. Arleen, who is the patient coordinator helped me so much through my journey and she went above and beyond in SO many ways. I am so grateful to have met a wonderful group of people and I think I chose the best. Dr. Pfeifer is also extremely good at what she does! They all genuinely want the best for you and it shows. When you have concerns, they are there to lift you up and make sure you are 100% okay. Arleen was there for me every step of the journey and she's still there for me even 3months after the surgery. I am SO grateful for everyone!

Breast Augmentation

Dr. Pfeifer has a really great aesthetic eye. I showed her pictures of the look I wanted to achieve with my implants, and she did an amazing job. Now that it has been a couple months, the implants have settled and I love the way it looks. The implants were well placed, they're symmetrical, and the size is proportional to my body. I love how they look.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Dr. Pfeifer cosmetics taste is completely aligned with mine. More subtle. Also Dr. Pfeifer spends a lot of time responding questions and asking bet own to make sure she understands fully my needs. Dr. Pfeifer has the best bedside manners and her staff is extraordinarily competent and helpful.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Excellent results!

Breast Reduction

It was amazing from start to post-op. Maureen was so comprehensive in her information and instructions but most importantly so caring and always available to help - fantastic. And Dr. Pfeifer is simply the best and I'm deeply grateful she was my surgeon.

Tummy Tuck

Dr. Pfeifer did an amazing job. Her and her staff have the best bedside manner and I can't say enough how patient and well informed the staff was.

Breast Lift

I truly couldn't be more satisfied with Dr. Pfeifer, Arlene, Maureen and the entire team! From my first virtual consult to today (~2 months post surgery) the commitment everyone has shown to making sure I was fully educated, happy with the results, etc. has been unwavering. You guys are always there to answer all my questions (no matter how ridiculous) and ensure I am comfortable and happy! Don't have one negative thing to say about the entire process and I look forward to continuing to see Dr. Pfeifer for years to come!

Breast Implant Revision

Personal approach combined with extremely experienced. Honest but never causing panic when explaining needed procedure or testing.

Breast Augmentation

Dr. Pfeifer and her team made me feel so safe, heard and comfortable from the very beginning to the very end! All of my questions were answered, I even learned more about a breast augmentation that I realized I should know! I went through with the surgery and felt like I was being taken care of by my own family. Everyone was so warm, nurturing and very attentive to my recover! Couldn't have asked for a more successful surgery and excellent recovery!

Injectable Fillers

Dr. Pfeiffer is a kind and very generous person. I appreciate her knowledge and expertise in what she does. After meeting her I will only see her and feel so appreciative to have met and found such a wonderful physician. She goes above and beyond and spends so much time with her patients. I never feel rushed and actually enjoy our conversations. I could go on and on about her. Again, I'm very thankful to have finally met a physician I can trust and who provides excellent work. Thank you!

Breast Augmentation

Dr. Pfeifer has been very attentive and supportive throughout the whole process. She gave me exactly what we discussed. I am very pleased with the outcome.

Breast Reduction

The level of bedside manner, pre-surgery preparation, post surgery care phone calls and follow up visits are impeccable. Dr. Pfeifer’s attention to detail cannot be matched. Dr. Pfeifer is extremely detail oriented. I am beyond satisfied with the surgical results.

Breast Lift

I was SO over the moon happy with how this turned out. I went in for a breast lift and implant and I aiming for a natural look. I was also prepared for a lollipop scar. Dr. Pfeifer is a true genius who managed to make me feel so comfortable during the whole process, did the procedure without a lollipop scar and I have to say you can barely tell that I had a procedure done. It looks so natural and perfect. Literally over the moon happy. Dr. Pfeifer and Maureen made sure I was SO comfortable with everything. The attention to detail before the procedure equally matched the level of attention right after surgery. From multiple calls, and texts to make sure I was good for a week after the surgery to general check in texts from Maureen, and Dr. Pfeifer so accessible, I felt really well taken care of! And not to mention the results exceeded my expectations. After thinking about this procedure for 10 years, this really was amazing.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Doctor is so wonderful. Completely trust her like no other!!! She truly listens. Staff is so friendly and helpful beyond belief. They go above and beyond.


Maureen was great before and after surgery. Dr. Pfeifer is very knowledgeable and made me feel very comfortable. Very happy with my experience.

Breast Implant Revision

Excellent skills. Great communication. Great doctor and staff.

Breast Implant Removal

Dr. Pfeifer and Maureen were non-stop in contact with me before during and after the procedure. Dr. Pfeifer is an absolute master at her craft and compassionate at the same time. They both helped me stay calm through a very difficult time.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Well run office with competent, cordial, knowledgeable staff. I always enjoy my conversations with Dr. Pfeifer. Great results with little or no discomfort.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

First appointment of the day. Was quick and easy especially in times of COVID.

Injectable Fillers

I love Tracy... She is always accommodating, does a great job on what I need, I usually do a half lip injection half Botox which she disperses a little on my crows feet and did my marionette lines very lightly... GREAT I love it... and this was new for me ... and she always gives me a break too on payment. Thank you Tracy and Staff.