Make healthcare choices based on 100% authentic reviews.

Provider Scorecard

participant since 11/30/2011

Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD

96.8% Patient Satisfaction based on 200 ratings

Scroll down to read and filter verified real patient reviews for Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD . You can also see locations, or contact Tracy M. Pfeifer right here at RealPatientRatings®.

Based on 200 ratings
5 stars (173)
4 stars (24)
3 stars (1)
2 stars (2)
1 star (0)
Doctor's bedside manner
Medical support team
Admin staff
Care & concern
Educated me
Wait time
Value for the price
Likelihood to recommend
Facility & amenities


About, locations & contact info

About Tracy M. Pfeifer:

Dr. Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD, MS is a plastic surgeon specializing in all of the most rewarding and beneficial procedures in cosmetic surgery, including breast augmentation, body contouring, facial plastic surgery, and skin rejuvenation procedures. Dr. Pfeifer offers a special emphasis on surgery of the breast, with extensive training and experience that has distinguished her within the field.

As one of New York's elite few female plastic surgeons, Dr. Pfeifer is well attuned to the aesthetic concerns of her patients. Her specialized training in plastic surgery of the breast further distinguishes her within the field. 

Dr. Pfeifer's philosophy is a commitment to excellence and providing each patient with a warm and personalized focus on their needs. Through patient education, we help patients make informed choices that are in their best interest. The ultimate goal is a satisfied patient with an excellent aesthetic result.

Board Certification

American Board of Plastic Surgery
American Board of Surgery

Contact This Provider

1125 5th Avenue New York, NY 10128

25 Montauk Highway Quogue, NY 11959

Sort options
Search filters
Service type
How we do it Why you can trust our reviews Find a provider
Active filters: Click X to remove any filter or reset all
All filters are off. Customize your search by using the sidebar options below.
Tracy M. Pfeifer, MD Reviews (144)

Injectable Fillers

Yes [highly satisfied].

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Dr. P and her staff are totally understanding and very professional. Friendly with a capital F. Can't wait for my next appt.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

[Highly satisfied] Overall.

Breast Reduction

The entire staff is completely informed and are able to answer any questions you may have. The explanations are thorough and comforting.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Appointment time as scheduled, consultation and suggestions offered. [Single best thing is...] Lessening of sunken facial areas.


From the moment I saw Dr. Pfeifer, I was relieved of any embarrassment, and throughout the entire pre-op period I was comfortable. The surgery was easier than I could imagine possible (dignity intact) and the results are beyond beautiful. The post-op period is easy. Other than no sex for six weeks, no big deal. I think Dr. Pfeifer is the doctor to go to for this highly sensitive surgery. I never for a moment felt uncomfortable and the results are so amazingly pretty. The hardest part for me was actually making the appointment and putting into words what the problem was. This doctor is awesome. She also arranged for me to get pre-op clearance from a doctor that she is associated with (I was too embarrassed to go to my own primary care doctor) and she kept my reason private! So, wow. I should have called her years ago.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Doctor Pfeifer is great. I am very happy with her work. It looks natural, she doesn't over do.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Great experience.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Doctor has a great eye for just how much is required, her staff is professional and wonderfully friendly at the same time.

Tummy Tuck

My abdomen was disfigured horribly after an intestinal surgery. Having a tummy tuck has given me back my self esteem.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Tracy is the very best!

BOTOX® Cosmetic

[Highly satisfied with...] The outcome.

Mole Removal

Dr. Pfeifer met with me on many occasions, a consultation prior to the procedure, and many times afterwards for check ups. It was just a small mole removal on my face, but she really treated it like it was just as important as a nose job, or breast implants. I felt taken care of.


Dr. Pfiefer is wonderful and very knowledgeable about injectables. I don't trust anyone else.

Breast Augmentation

Boobs look perfect and natural. Great customer service, made me feel extremely comfortable. Overall awesome experience. I feel like a whole new person with my new boobs. You can’t even tell they were fake. I did the gummy bear implants and they look and feel super natural.

Breast Lift

I look and feel terrific. I had a small issue with one of the scars and it was immediately addressed and corrected by the Dr. [Single best thing is...] My results and the care that was given by the Dr. and her staff.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

The results were extremely poor, compared to previous procedures with other providers. Botox has little or no results. I can move my forehead and lip area, the same way prior to procedure. Fillers did not make a difference in lines around lips or forehead. Perhaps I can no longer be helped. That is the impression I left with, that I was too far gone to be helped.

Mole Removal

For a simple procedure, Dr. Pfeifer took ample time with me to explain the procedure in detail, project outcome, and follow up to make sure everything was healing as possible. I didn't expect that level of service for a mole removal, and was pleasantly surprised.

BOTOX® Cosmetic

Dr. Pfeifer is an excellent Dr. who takes time to understand my situation. She has been working with me for 2 years with my problem. She has made me feel relief and Confident we can fix my problem

Breast Lift

The staff of the New York office is fabulous. Maureen is very dedicated to her job and makes made me feel as if I was the only patient the doctor has! The office is beautiful and Dr. Pfeiffer is very caring, has a great eye and did everything to make sure I was satisfied with my results. I also had Botox during this follow up visit, I had never had it before and it was a painless procedure and I love my results. I will be back for sure. I no longer try and hide my breasts -I feel confident and my breasts are more in proportion to my size. I feel younger too - I have worked out my entire life and there was nothing I could do to improve the look of my sagging breasts. I finally got the courage to go ahead and have a breast lift and I am so glad I did.